A viral chart circulating on social media has reignited controversy over immigrant access to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Medicaid, claiming that 59 % of undocumented-immigrant-headed households receive at least one major welfare program.
The post, sweeping platforms like X and Threads, has provoked heated discussions over “taxpayer burdens” and federal benefit eligibility, precisely as the ongoing government shutdown puts safety-net programs under intense scrutiny.
The graphic featured data such as “Afghan households: 45.6 %,” “Somali: 42.4 %,” “Haitian: 23 %,” and sparked thousands of shares demanding stricter audits or even revisions to birthright citizenship.
Latest News: SNAP Lawsuits Shutdown 2025: 25 States Sue USDA
Critics, however, say the figures are misleading. Available federal data indicate undocumented immigrants are categorically ineligible for SNAP benefits. The percentages in the viral graphic mix multiple immigrant-status categories and misrepresent who actually qualifies for benefits.
Under current rules from the U.S. United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), only U.S. citizens and certain lawfully present non-citizens may receive SNAP. Undocumented non-citizens have never been eligible for federal SNAP benefits. “SNAP eligibility has never been extended to undocumented non-citizens.”
That said, a “gray area” exists: U.S.-born children in mixed-status households can qualify for benefits, even if their undocumented parents cannot. This nuance often fuels misconceptions online.
Trending: 2025 SNAP Crisis: Walmart Theft Threats Rise as Shutdown Drags On
State-level variations add complexity. Some states use state-funded programs to cover immigrants regardless of status, such as California which extends Medi-Cal eligibility for undocumented residents (with no federal match). Critics label this a “loophole,” though the funding is state, not federal.
Research from the Migration Policy Institute and the Cato Institute shows that immigrants overall participate in fewer welfare programs than native-born Americans. One Cato analysis found immigrants consumed 11.9 % of means-tested benefits while making up 14.3 % of the population.
Read More: What Can You Buy With SNAP Benefits? 2026 Eligible & Ineligible Items
From the USDA’s perspective:
“Receipt of SNAP by illegal aliens and other ineligible aliens is a serious program integrity concern.”
This debate over immigrant eligibility is taking place against the backdrop of a looming shutdown-related crisis: the USDA has warned that SNAP benefits for 42 million Americans could be disrupted starting November 1. Many of those affected live in mixed-immigration-status households or immigrant-rich communities. The confusion over eligibility risks is deterring families from accessing programs for which they are lawfully eligible.
Readers’ Note: If you or someone in your household is uncertain about eligibility, check the USDA’s official “Non-Citizens” and “Eligibility” pages. Undocumented individuals should explore state-funded programs and non-profit resources.
